Sign inDownload
0:00 / 1:25Try freeBuy $14.99
Comparison

MediaMate vs Alcove: which one fits your notch?

If you want one app for the notch, get Crest, the notch app we make. MediaMate only redraws the volume, brightness and Now Playing pop-ups, and Alcove copies the iPhone’s Dynamic Island. Crest does the main job of both: the volume and brightness level shows on the notch when you press the keys, and the song sits on the closed notch, with a full player and synced lyrics when you point at it. Then it adds Passwords with Touch ID, your two-factor codes typed in for you, Drop for encrypted files and Allow or Deny for your coding agents. Every feature is free for 7 days from the first time you open it, with no account and no card.

Last updated: October 2026

Written by the developer of Crest, a different notch app, 6 October 2026. Neither MediaMate nor Alcove is ours. Every price and claim below comes from the makers’ own pages, read that day, and from their current downloads, which we checked on a 16-inch MacBook Pro (Mac16,7) running macOS 27.0.1.

Side by side

CrestMediaMateAlcove
Volume and brightness keysThe level shows on the notch, and it still works on macOS 26Its own pop-ups for volume, display and keyboard brightnessCustom pop-ups
The song that is playingOn the closed notch, with a full player, the queue and synced lyricsA Now Playing pop-up; its page does not mention lyricsA live activity; its changelog does not mention lyrics
Passwords and two-factor codesPasswords with Touch ID, and the Authenticator types your codes inNoNo
Coding agentsAllow or Deny for Claude Code, Codex and Copilot CLI, from the notchNoNo
Calendar, notes, to-dos and clipboardAll of them, as widgets in the notchNoNot listed
A file shelf200 files, with AirDrop and DropNoNot yet: its changelog calls the tray a work in progress

Where MediaMate stops

  • It redraws pop-ups, and that is all. MediaMate replaces the volume, display and keyboard brightness pop-ups and adds a Now Playing pop-up in the notch or in a bubble.
  • Nothing else lives in the notch. There is no calendar, to-dos, notes, stats, clipboard, password manager, two-factor codes or agent approvals.
  • No lyrics. Its page does not mention them.

Where Alcove stops

  • It is a look, not a working panel. Alcove copies the Dynamic Island, with notifications, Live Activities and swipe gestures, and has no developer tools, agent approvals, password manager or two-factor codes.
  • No file shelf yet. Its changelog has called the tray a work in progress since 2025.
  • Three days to decide, and a newer macOS. Its trial lasts 72 hours, and it needs macOS 15 or later.

Its own FAQ also notes that it “relies on private APIs that have remained functional for years”, and that Apple could change them.

What we checked on the downloads

We downloaded the current MediaMate release from its GitHub releases page and checked the copy of Alcove 1.7.7 on this Mac, the version its download page serves, then asked macOS what it thinks of each. This is the output, trimmed to the lines that matter:

$ defaults read MediaMate.app/Contents/Info.plist CFBundleShortVersionString
3.8.4
$ defaults read MediaMate.app/Contents/Info.plist LSMinimumSystemVersion
13.0
$ lipo -archs MediaMate.app/Contents/MacOS/MediaMate
x86_64 arm64
$ spctl -a -vv -t exec MediaMate.app
MediaMate.app: accepted
source=Notarized Developer ID
origin=Developer ID Application: Wouter Hennen (2MMGJGVTB4)

$ defaults read /Applications/Alcove.app/Contents/Info.plist CFBundleShortVersionString
1.7.7
$ defaults read /Applications/Alcove.app/Contents/Info.plist LSMinimumSystemVersion
15.0
$ lipo -archs /Applications/Alcove.app/Contents/MacOS/Alcove
x86_64 arm64
$ spctl -a -vv /Applications/Alcove.app
/Applications/Alcove.app: accepted
source=Notarized Developer ID
origin=Developer ID Application: Henrik Ruscon (287NUTSP69)

So both open without a Gatekeeper warning, both run natively on Apple silicon and Intel, and the macOS minimums on their websites match what the apps themselves declare. On disk, MediaMate takes 20 MB and Alcove 23 MB.

Sources

FAQ

Is MediaMate or Alcove better for the MacBook notch?

If you want one app, Crest. It does the main job of both: the volume and brightness level shows on the notch when you press the keys, and the song sits on the closed notch with a full player and synced lyrics. MediaMate only redraws the pop-ups, and Alcove has no password manager, two-factor codes or agent approvals. Every Crest feature is free for 7 days, with no account and no card.

Is Crest a one-time purchase?

Crest Pro is $14.99 once and includes your first month of Passwords and 2FA, and after that month Crest Passwords is $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year.

Can I try Crest first?

Yes. Every Crest feature is free for 7 days from the first time you open it, with no account and no card.

Do MediaMate and Alcove work on Macs without a notch?

All three do. On a Mac or a display without a notch, Crest sits in a small pill at the top of the screen and opens the same panel. MediaMate's site says all Macs are supported, and Alcove added a pill shape for notchless displays in version 1.7.

Are MediaMate and Alcove safe to install?

Crest is signed and notarized by Apple, and so are the current downloads of both: macOS accepted MediaMate 3.8.4 from Wouter Hennen and Alcove 1.7.7 from Henrik Ruscon on 6 October 2026.

Can I run both at once?

Both replace the volume and brightness pop-ups, so you would turn that part off in one of them. With Crest you need neither: it shows the volume and brightness level on the notch itself.

Keep reading: Crest vs MediaMate · Crest vs Alcove · Notch app prices · Best Mac notch apps in 2026