Sign inDownload
0:00 / 1:25Try freeBuy $14.99

How to change the default password manager on a Mac

macOS has one list for it, and Chrome keeps its own.

7 days free, no card. macOS 14 or later.

The short answer

You installed a new password manager, and Apple's Passwords still pops up first on every sign-in page. That's because macOS has no single "default" button. It keeps a list of apps allowed to fill your logins, and more than one can be on at once. On macOS 15 and later the list is in System Settings > General > AutoFill & Passwords, under AutoFill from. On macOS 14 it's System Settings > Passwords > Password Options. Leave the app you want ticked and untick the rest, and it becomes your default. Chrome has its own password manager, so it needs one more switch.

Pro

Crest fills from the notch

On a sign-in page the notch offers the login. Approve with Touch ID and Crest fills it in.

Pro

The code comes next

When the next page asks for a two-factor code, the notch offers that too.

Step 1: choose the app in System Settings

Install the password manager first and open it once, so macOS knows it can fill. Then:

  • macOS 15 and later: open the Apple menu, then System Settings > General > AutoFill & Passwords. Under AutoFill from, turn on the app you want. Turn off Passwords too if you don't want Apple's app offering logins next to it.
  • macOS 14: open System Settings > Passwords, unlock it with Touch ID or your Mac's password, and click Password Options. Tick the app you want in the list of apps that fill, and untick the ones you don't.

Turning Passwords off doesn't delete anything. Your Apple passwords stay in the Passwords app, and you can tick it again any time.

Step 2: Safari

Safari fills from the apps you left on in Step 1. Most password managers also ship a Safari extension that fills without typing and offers to save new logins. Open Safari > Settings > Extensions, tick your password manager, and allow it on every website. If you skip this, sign-in pages can still show two offers at once, Apple's and the new app's.

Step 3: Chrome

Chrome doesn't read the list in System Settings for passwords. It uses Google Password Manager until you tell it not to.

  1. Install your password manager's Chrome extension from the Chrome Web Store.
  2. In Chrome, open the menu (the three dots at the top right) and choose Passwords and autofill, then Google Password Manager.
  3. Click Settings in the sidebar, then turn off Offer to save passwords and Sign in automatically.

Chrome keeps the passwords it already saved. If you want them in the new app, export them from Chrome first, then remove them from Google Password Manager.

How to make Crest the one that fills

We built Passwords into Crest, our notch app for the Mac, because a password manager shouldn't need its own window. On a sign-in page the notch offers the login, you approve with Touch ID, and Crest fills it in. When the next page asks for a two-factor code, the notch offers that too, from the same place.

  1. Open Passwords in the notch and press Set up Passwords. Crest walks you through it: sign in, Touch ID and a recovery key.
  2. Let Crest fill. Press Turn on… in Crest's setup. On macOS 15 and later, macOS asks right there whether Crest may fill, so you never go looking for the switch. On macOS 14, Crest opens Password Options for you.
  3. Turn off Apple's AutoFill. Crest's next card, Turn off Apple's AutoFill, has an Open AutoFill settings button that lands on the right pane. Untick Passwords and leave Crest ticked, so only Crest offers your logins.
  4. Turn on the Safari extension. It comes inside Crest, so there's nothing to download. Press Open Safari Settings and tick Crest.
  5. Bring your passwords in. Press Import and pick Apple Passwords, 1Password, Bitwarden or a CSV file.

Add Crest Passwords from the Chrome Web Store once, and Crest fills your logins in Chrome too. Without it, the notch types your logins into Chrome and any other browser once Crest is allowed in System Settings > Privacy & Security > Accessibility, the same way it types two-factor codes.

Filling, adding and syncing passwords and 2FA codes is free for your first month, then comes with Crest Passwords or a Crest Cloud plan. Reading, copying, searching and exporting them never pause. Every setting is in the Passwords guide, and there's more on Crest Passwords.

Try Crest free for 7 days, no card, and let the notch fill your next sign-in.

7 days free, no card. macOS 14 or later. Refunds within 7 days if something is wrong.

Questions5
Can I have two password managers on at once?

Yes. macOS lets several apps fill, and each one you leave on can offer a login. That's why sign-in pages sometimes show two offers. Untick every app but one in AutoFill & Passwords and only that app offers.

Does turning off Apple Passwords delete my passwords?

No. It only stops Apple's app from offering logins. Everything stays in the Passwords app, and you can turn it back on in the same place.

Why don't I see my password manager under AutoFill from?

The app has to support AutoFill on the Mac, and macOS only lists it after you've opened it once. Quit and reopen the app, then look again. If it still isn't there, the app fills through its browser extension only.

Does Chrome use the Mac's AutoFill setting?

Not for passwords. Chrome fills from Google Password Manager or from a password manager's Chrome extension, so turn off Offer to save passwords in Chrome too.

Can Crest be my default password manager?

Yes. Turn Crest on under AutoFill from, untick Passwords, and turn on Crest's Safari extension. Crest's setup has a button for each step.